There’s a quiet but fascinating dispute brewing in Europe’s smartphone industry. As the EU’s new Ecodesign rules kicked in this summer, most major brands simply stretched their software support timelines to six or seven years and moved on. It looked like a smooth transition toward longer-lasting phones.
Motorola, however, isn’t convinced — and its pushback comes down to one surprisingly powerful word in the regulation.
The Ecodesign rules (Commission Regulation 2023/1670), which came into effect on June 20, cover everything from repairability standards to battery durability. But the part that drew the most attention was software longevity. On its own website, the European Commission confidently stated that the rules would ensure “operating system upgrades for longer periods (minimum 5 years from the date on which the last unit of a product model is no longer placed on the market).”
That sounded like a straightforward requirement. And most smartphone makers quickly changed their software update policy to comply with the new rule. But Motorola took a closer look at the actual legal text instead. Buried in Annex 2, title 1.2, paragraph 6(a), the key line reads:
“From the date of end of placement on the market to at least 5 years after that date, manufacturers […] shall, if they provide security updates, corrective updates or functionality updates to an operating system, make such updates available at no cost…”
That “if” changes everything. The regulation doesn’t explicitly force manufacturers to provide updates — only that, if they do, those updates must remain free for at least five years. Since no company charges for patches anyway, Motorola argues the rules don’t actually require longer support.
As a result, the brand continues to ship phones in Europe with relatively shorter timelines, sometimes barely hitting four years. The Motorola Edge 70, for instance, is reportedly eligible for up to four major OS updates and six years of security updates in Europe
Whether Motorola’s interpretation stands remains to be seen, but the situation highlights how much can hinge on a single word — and how regulations that sound clear in a press release can get far murkier once you read the fine print.
Don’t miss a thing! Join our Telegram community for instant updates and grab our free daily newsletter for the best tech stories!
For more daily updates, please visit our News Section.
(Via)
Comments